United Nations Economic and Social Council
Commission on Human Rights
Sub-Commision on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities
Working Group on Contemporary Forms of Slavery
22nd Session

Geneva 1997

Report by: Mr Cleophas Mally
consultant, Director WAO-Afrique


It is with great pleasure that I address your commission for the second time, the first date beind April 1995 when I exposed to you the situation of child domestics in Togo. Today, permit to raise another subject of concern: the trafficking of children from Togo to other destinations. We cannot remain inactive and silent facing the drama in which the children of Togo still live, despite the decisions made at the world summit on the sexual explotation of children for commermial ends which took place in Stockholm in August in August 1996.

The traffic of children is a current practice among the countries of the sub region of Western Africa. The phenomenon spreads and institutionalizes itself through informal networks for the exportation of children to the Gulf countries and to Europe. WAO-Afrique was contacted by a young girl from Togo who was actually in Lebanon, who wrote to relate the conditions of her recruitment, life and work and to inform us of the existence of relay points in Africa for this flourishing commerce. While WAO-Afrique undertook the internal proceedings (security services, police),and the proceedings outside of the country (with Anti-International and Agir Ensemble) to conduct an investigation, traffickers of children were arrested in Lome and Cotonou. At the same time, the Minister of Foreign Affairs received a letter from his Charge d'Affaires at the Gabon Embassy that signaled the existence of trafficking of children in that country.

These written testimonies and arrests touched the governmental conscience regarding this problem. I would like to remind you that Togo has ratified numerous international instruments which have implications for the children and their families. In particular:

-the Convention on the Rights of the Child;
-the 1973 OIT Convention number 138 concerning the minimum age of the child to be employed;
-the 1949 Convention for the trade of human beings and the explotation of prostitution of others;
-the global Declaration in favor of the survival, protection and development of the child and its action plan.

The Togolese Code for people and the family, promulgated in January 1988, protects the child in general. However, there is no legal text which specifically regulates the departure of children outside of the counties borders.

Though the traffic of children has been made clesr by concrete facts, for the moment it still does not constitute a priority at a national level. Therefore there does not exit a visible program to eradicate the problem. This situation is explained by the following:
-a chronic lack of information and data on the phenomenon;
- absense of campaigns to increase public awareness and sensitvity and social mobilization;
- the chronic lack of technical competence with regard to possibilities and modalities of action;
- the illiteracy of parents and the lack of education of girl-children
- the absence of viable subltitute solutions to aid the parents in keeping the children with them.

WAO-Afrique has pursued its initiative into the investigation on the trafficking of children with the financial contributions of Anti-Slavery International and Agir Ensemble. The public has alredy been warned of the problem. Nevertheless,it has been difficult to acquire the necessary information to accuse the people involved. The trafficking phenomena is becoming more hidden and more practisced in shielding itself from any control. The children are often afraid of their parents and do not easily give information about the trafficking which they the object.

The study identifies four types of trafficking:

- parents who organize themslves to sell their children;
- children found on the street and picked up by people with harmful who remove their organs for occult practices;
- parents who hire their children out for a time judged necessary to repay a contractual dept
- parents who place their children in the care of another person (parents, friends, neighbours or strangers) who then place them either in Togo or abroad.

It also reveals several channels of placement and trafficking:

The different channels through which children are moved can be summed up as a circuit which, within the country, brings children from rural zones to urban centres from which they are moved out of the country. The immigration centers which have been identified are the prefectures of Vo, Yoto, Zio (in the South), Kloto (in the South-west), Tchaoudjo and Assoli (in the Center). Once out of the country, the children leaving Togo are dreined to Ghana, the Cote d'Ivoire and Burkina Faso. The principle channel transports through Benin, Nigeria via Gabon or the European Union Countries and especially the Gulf countries. WAO-Afrique is aware of the ecistence of other immigration centers which have yet to be identified.

The traffic of children especially concerns young girls between the ages of eight and twelve. Children as young as six have also been found. There is a very distinct preference on the part of parents to place girls rather than boys in the service of parents, be they close or far away. According to the investigation, the phenomenon affects 80 per cent of children in rural environments of which 75 per cent of the girls have never set foot in a school. More than 50% of them are younger than 14 years old.

The obstacles in the fight for the elimination of this phenomenon are of two types; those which follow from the very nature of the problem and those which are linked to the absence of institutional, administrative and legal mechanisms.

Possible solutions

The resolution of this problem of trafficking in Togo is practically impossible due to the abundance of the migrations of infantile man-power in the sub-region. At the time of the last meeting (February 1997) of the countries of the Conseil de l'Entente (Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Nigeria and Togo) the problem was raised before the concerned countries. It is therefore urgent that a working relationship is established between NGOs and certain governmental services in different countries with the goal of exchanging experiences, to conduct first hand research, to inform and launch campaigns, to carry out speeches for the defence, to propose solutions of substitution relating to these children and to elaborate a regional plan of action for the struggle against exploitation and the trafficking of children in West Africa.

This regional plan of action will permit the organization and convergence of national programmes (governments, NGOs) for the eradication of trafficking and the exploitation of child labour.

In Togo, since 1992, WAO -Afrique and other NGOs have worked together in a national coalition to go forward with actions for the protection of children. In close cooperation with national and international NGOs, several governments, churches and the media, we have succeeded in gaining the support of more and more partners for our cause. This was the case with the s tudy on the exploitation ofchild domestic workers which was made in 1994 in Togo thanks to the financial aid of Anti-Slavery International and the French NGO Agir Ensemble de Droits de l'Homme. It is this support which allows us even to this day to come before you to prove the existence of trafficking of children in Togo. whichtook place in 1994 in Togo thanks to the financial aid of Anti-Slavery International which permits us even to this day to come before you to prove the existence of the trafficking of children in Togo through their support and the support of the French NGO Agir Ensemble pour les Droits de l'Homme.

Thus, together or separately, WAO-Afrique, Radda Barnen, Child Rights in collaboration with UNICEF-Togo, the United States Embassy in Togo, the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the cooperation of the Togolese Minister of Justice and Human Rights have sponsored or organised several seminars and working meetings on the Convention of the Rights of the Child in general and the exploitation of children in particular.

At the same time, since 1994, we have launched with great success an informational campaign on the traffic of children from Togo to other countries.

The phenomenon of trafficking children in Togo could only be resolved by a concerted regional action involving all interested partners.

We take this occasion to call upon BIT, UNICEF, UNESCO, PNUD, upon the group of NGOs on the Convention of the Rights of the Child and especially on the Commission on Human Rights of the United Nations to work together in a partnership to reach a global solution while contributing to the elaboration of a regional plan of action in the struggle against the exploitation and the trafficking of children in West Africa.

Finally, the rapid investigation into the traffic of children in Togo initiatedby WAO-Afrique already allows us to undertake information campaigns,raising public compassion and mobility regarding the problem. WAO-Afrique echoesthe necessity of organising an exhaustive research on a national level with the goal of determining the numbers of corroborators, the size of the problem, and establishing a systematic collection of information on the children who have been the victims of trafficking.